Recently, another transplant trial in Parkinson’s disease was reported as a failure (Spheramine). It seemed rational many years ago when scientists proposed cell replacement as the penultimate neurorestorative therapy for Parkinson’s disease, but sometimes rational is not enough. The track record, however has been less than expected. There have however, been many lessons learned and the experience will hopefully help us toward better therapies in the future.
Several preliminary open-label pilot studies of various transplant techniques for human Parkinson’s disease were observed to have varying degrees of success. Transplants with adrenal medullary cells and then human embryonic dopaminergic cells were sought as a potential treatment for advanced Parkinson’s disease. Two independent double blinded studies (investigator blind and examiner blind) failed to reveal adequate efficacy when compared to a sham group (a group who received burr holes in the head but no transplant), although the younger patients seemed to display some positive motor benefits. The most recent exclamation point on transplant therapy occurred when Spheramine was recently reported as a failure. Spheramine was a cell based therapy for transplantation into Parkinson’s disease brains in a double blinded trial (half got spheramine and half got sham surgery). Spheramine consisted of human retinal epithelial cells attached to what was called a microcarrier support matrix which was designed to help survival. One of the rationales for the study was the finding that inner retinal cells could produce dopamine. Recent positive unblinded studies of Spheramine led to the blinded trial which did not meet its primary outcome (15).
There are many potential reasons for the failure of the transplant trial experiences. Perhaps the most compelling reason for failure is the complex nature of the multiple motor and non-motor circuits affected(1-5) in Parkinson’s disease. The transplants only attempted to replace dopaminergic cells in one degenerated areas of the brain (the putamen). Future approaches may need to broaden their scope to account for the many brain systems involved in the pathogenesis of Parkinson’s disease. Of particular interest is that Parkinson’s disease is now known to be motor as well as nonmotor (depression, anxiety, sexual dysfunction, etc.), and these nonmotor system deserve particular attention.
The use of sham surgery, or drilling burr holes in the skull but not implanting cells in half the patients in the transplant trials has drawn much ethical discussion. It is interesting that the open-label unblinded effects of the pilot surgery that led to the larger blinded trials were positive, but when a sham group was utilized the placebo effects cancelled out many of the potential benefits. Additionally, the group that received the transplanted cells also developed unacceptable side effects (e.g. dyskinesias), as compared to those in the sham group. Finally, if the study was positive and safe, the sham group would have been ultimately been offered the transplanted cells(6-16). Sham surgery therefore proved a reasonable and important approach.
Patients enrolled in both of the large double blind placebo-controlled trials for transplantation of embryonic dopaminergic cells developed a unique and never before observed side effect referred to as runaway dyskinesia. The term runaway dyskinesia has been coined because the extra movements (or dyskinesias) occurred in both the “off” medication state as well as in the “on” medication state. Normally, dyskinesias in patients without transplants only occurs in the “on” medication state. It is still speculative as to why this side effect occurred in the transplanted patients, but most experts believe that in some way the grafted tissue reconstituted the circuitry in an aberrant way (9, 17, 18).
One of the most interesting findings derived from the transplant studies has been imaging data, and also post-mortem data that has revealed that the transplanted cells have survived and prospered in their new home. This finding is encouraging for the future of the transplant field, however it reminds us that the gold standard for improvement is not the MRI (magnetic resonance imaging) scan, but rather the patient(18, 19). Multiple groups have reported the phenomenon of spreading neurodegeneration from the host tissue into the newly grafted cells. Careful examination of post-mortem brains following embryonic fetal cell transplants has shown evidence of the Lewy Body and other neurodegenerative features in the previously unaffected cells transplanted into the host. Scientists are hopeful that the explanation of this phenomenon will help unlock some of the mysteries surrounding Parkinson’s disease(19, 20).
It will be important as the Parkinson’s disease transplant field moves forward into new areas such as stem cells and gene therapy, that the lessons learned from the failed transplant trials are incorporated into new strategies for success. It should be pointed out that hope should remain strong as we have accomplished the proof of principle in making cells survive and prosper after transplant—now we need to focus on improving their functionality and reconstituting a complex broken circuitry.
For more information on the use of stem cells in treating and researching Parkinson’s disease, listen to this episode 17 of our podcast, Substantial Matters: Life and Science of Parkinson’s: Stem Cells and Parkinson’s.
- Alexander GE, Crutcher MD, DeLong MR. Basal ganglia-thalamocortical circuits: parallel substrates for motor, oculomotor, "prefrontal" and "limbic" functions. Prog Brain Res 1990;85:119-146.
- Alexander GE, DeLong MR, Strick PL. Parallel organization of functionally segregated circuits linking basal ganglia and cortex. Annu Rev Neurosci 1986;9:357-381.
- Braak H, Bohl JR, Muller CM, Rub U, de Vos RA, Del Tredici K. Stanley Fahn Lecture 2005: The staging procedure for the inclusion body pathology associated with sporadic Parkinson's disease reconsidered. Mov Disord 2006;21:2042-2051.
- Braak H, Muller CM, Rub U, et al. Pathology associated with sporadic Parkinson's disease--where does it end? J Neural Transm Suppl 2006:89-97.
- Braak H, Sastre M, Bohl JR, de Vos RA, Del Tredici K. Parkinson's disease: lesions in dorsal horn layer I, involvement of parasympathetic and sympathetic pre- and postganglionic neurons. Acta Neuropathol 2007;113:421-429.
- Bjorklund A. Cell therapy for Parkinson's disease: problems and prospects. Novartis Found Symp 2005;265:174-186; discussion 187, 204-211.
- Breysse N, Carlsson T, Winkler C, Bjorklund A, Kirik D. The functional impact of the intrastriatal dopamine neuron grafts in parkinsonian rats is reduced with advancing disease. J Neurosci 2007;27:5849-5856.
- Goetz CG, Wuu J, McDermott MP, et al. Placebo response in Parkinson's disease: comparisons among 11 trials covering medical and surgical interventions. Mov Disord 2008;23:690-699.
- Graff-Radford J, Foote KD, Rodriguez RL, et al. Deep brain stimulation of the internal segment of the globus pallidus in delayed runaway dyskinesia. Arch Neurol 2006;63:1181-1184.
- Hall VJ, Li JY, Brundin P. Restorative cell therapy for Parkinson's disease: a quest for the perfect cell. Semin Cell Dev Biol 2007;18:859-869.
- Korecka JA, Verhaagen J, Hol EM. Cell-replacement and gene-therapy strategies for Parkinson's and Alzheimer's disease. Regen Med 2007;2:425-446.
- Linazasoro G. Cell therapy for Parkinson's disease: only young onset patients allowed? Reflections about the results of recent clinical trials with cell therapy and the progression of Parkinson's disease. Cell Transplant 2006;15:463-473.
- Paul G. Cell transplantation for patients with Parkinson's disease. Handb Exp Pharmacol 2006:361-388.
- Polgar S, Ng J. A critical analysis of evidence for using sham surgery in Parkinson's disease: implications for public health. Aust N Z J Public Health 2007;31:270-274.
- Stover NP, Watts RL. Spheramine for treatment of Parkinson's disease. Neurotherapeutics 2008;5:252-259.
- Wijeyekoon R, Barker RA. Cell replacement therapy for Parkinson's disease. Biochim Biophys Acta 2008.
- Carlsson T, Winkler C, Lundblad M, Cenci MA, Bjorklund A, Kirik D. Graft placement and uneven pattern of reinnervation in the striatum is important for development of graft-induced dyskinesia. Neurobiol Dis 2006;21:657-668.
- Freed CR, Greene PE, Breeze RE, et al. Transplantation of embryonic dopamine neurons for severe Parkinson's disease. N Engl J Med 2001;344:710-719.
- Olanow CW, Goetz CG, Kordower JH, et al. A double-blind controlled trial of bilateral fetal nigral transplantation in Parkinson's disease. Ann Neurol 2003;54:403-414.
- Kordower JH, Chu Y, Hauser RA, Freeman TB, Olanow CW. Lewy body-like pathology in long-term embryonic nigral transplants in Parkinson's disease. Nat Med 2008;14:504-506.
You can find out more about our National Medical Director, Dr. Michael S. Okun, by also visiting the Center of Excellence, University of Florida Health Center for Movement Disorders and Neurorestoration. Dr. Okun is also the author of the Amazon #1 Parkinson's Best Seller 10 Secrets to a Happier Life and 10 Breakthrough Therapies for Parkinson's Disease.